The Situation
T&T once represented
the publicly-traded, British Vita, a billion dollar manufacturer of foam,
plastics and non-woven products. Vita had 93 locations in 23 countries
however they did not have a presence in the US, a market in which they
sought a strong platform. T&T was engaged by the Vita management team to
identify candidate companies in the US which met their specific criteria
and would be receptive to being acquired.
T&T identified and
contacted the ownership of approximately 30 companies which met the strict
Vita criteria. Following meetings and interviews with several of these
potential targets, Vita management selected the Evansville, Indiana based
compounder; The Matrixx Group. The company was a well managed
thermoplastic compounding operation with 5 plants in the US and sales in
excess of $100 million making it an attractive platform for Vita.
The Vita acquisition
team led by T&T began a series of meetings with Matrixx management and
their major shareholders to discuss a potential transaction with Vita.
Like any billion dollar company, Vita had many layers of management which
had to approve the deal and accordingly many meetings were necessary in
order to gain approval of each of the Vita managers. During this period,
which lasted over 9 months, Matrixx management obliged Vita’s request not
to speak with any other suitors about a potential deal. T&T, Vita and
Matrixx management spent hundreds of hours analyzing and negotiating all
the elements of the deal with the intention to close within 6o days.
The Set Back
Just about that time,
the private equity firm, Texas Pacific Group made an offer to acquire Vita
and take it private. While the Vita board initially rejected the bid, TPG
continued to sweeten the price until the board agreed in late March to the
deal terms. All major pending transactions including the Matrixx deal was
put on indefinite “hold”. Vita was acquired by for ₤668 million by TPG.
The hundreds of hours
of effort expended by the Matrixx management team had been wasted. The
fact was that the founder of the company, Ray Wright was no longer active
in the business and was seeking to monetize his ownership in Matrixx.
Meanwhile, the active managers in the company who were also shareholders
were in search of a strong financial partner in order to assist with the
significant growth the company was experiencing.
This time, the Matrixx
management and shareholders chose to take a proactive role in seeking the
right buyer and engaged T&T to advise them and to manage the transaction
process. The Matrixx Group was organized in a blend of seven sub-chapter S
and C corporations with the ownership unevenly split between approximately
50 shareholders.
The Solution
T&T immediately
recognized the potential problems that could come about regarding the
allocation of value to each of the entities and recommended the hiring of
an independent valuation expert to allocate the values between the various
companies. The next potential problem identified was the quality of the
financial statements which were not prepared by an outside CPA firm. T&T
suggested to management that the financials needed to be audited and a
regional accounting firm was hired. A final issue that needed attention
was the absence of environmental site assessments on the properties and an
engineering firm was hired to prepare site assessments on each of the
locations.
While that work was
being done by those firms, T&T in conjunction with Matrixx management
prepared the descriptive offering memorandum which was to be released to a
select number of potential financial partners. As an M&A specialist in the
plastics industry, T&T had already identified the private equity groups
who were the most likely candidates and therefore they would be most apt
to pay a maximum price to the Matrixx shareholders.
Once the financial
statements had been completed, confidentiality agreements were executed
and a select group of private equity sponsors were provided with the
offering memorandum. On the basis of the information in the memo, the
suitors submitted their offers for management and shareholder
consideration. The numerous offers had a wide range of values however
several were significantly higher than the others. These choices provided
the Matrixx team with the opportunity to select the candidate with whom
they were most comfortable and were most capable of getting the deal
closed.
After further
negotiation, Wind Point Partners was selected to move into final
confirmatory due diligence and negotiation of the purchase agreement. The
transaction closed smoothly thereafter. The purchase price was 35% higher
than the deal with British Vita and provided the opportunity for the
Matrixx management to own a significant interest in the company, an
element that was not offered in the Vita deal.
The Moral of the Story
The moral of the story
is that when company owners and managers decide to consider the sale of
all or a portion of their interests, they should not simply react to
overtures made by possible suitors. Instead, they should hire a
professional who can quietly and discreetly manage the process, create a
competitive selling environment and maximize the value to the selling
shareholders.
About Trudeau & Trudeau
Founded in 1982 by the Trudeau brothers,
Trudeau &
Trudeau Associates, Inc
is a full service
M&A advisory firm that provides merger and acquisition, corporate finance
and strategic consulting services to client companies and private equity
groups. Additional information available at:
www.trudeau-trudeau.com.
About The Matrixx Group
Founded in 1984, The
Matrixx Group is a leading independent compounder of thermoplastic resins
serving the power tool, lawn and garden, appliance, automotive, HVAC,
electronics and construction markets. The Matrixx Group’s product
portfolio features compounded grades of nylon, ABS, polycarbonate, PBT,
PET, polypropylene, polyethylene and engineering resin alloys. The
Matrixx Group is headquartered in Evansville, Ind. and currently has seven
manufacturing sites: five in the United States and two in Italy.
Additional information about The Matrixx Group is available at:
http://matrixxgroup.com.
About Wind Point
Partners
Wind Point Partners is
a private equity investment firm with $2 billion in capital under
management. Wind Point focuses on partnering with top caliber management
teams to acquire solid middle market businesses with a clear path to value
creation. Additional information about Wind Point is available at:
http://www.windpointpartners.com.